The Lehman formula is a sliding scale for an M&A success fee: 5% of the first $1 million of deal value, 4% of the second, 3% of the third, 2% of the fourth and 1% of everything above $4 million. On a $5 million sale that is $150,000, or 3% of the price. The double Lehman doubles each rate: 10%, 8%, 6%, 4% and 2%. Advisers treat both as a starting point and add minimum fees and retainers.
- Each rate applies only to its own slice of the price, never to the whole price.
- Lehman on $5 million is $150,000. Double Lehman on $5 million is $300,000.
- Define "deal value" in the engagement letter: earn-outs, seller notes and assumed debt change the fee.
- A success fee pays nothing when no sale closes.
What is the Lehman formula?
It is a tiered success fee, also called the Lehman scale or the 5-4-3-2-1 formula. Morgan & Westfield, an M&A advisory firm, states it as "5% on the first million, plus 4% on the second million, plus 3% on the third million, plus 2% on the fourth million, plus 1% after that."
According to Wikipedia's history of the formula, it "was first developed in the early 1970s by" Lehman Brothers for underwriting and capital raising, and was later used for sales of private companies.
| Slice of deal value | Rate | Fee on the full slice | Running total |
|---|---|---|---|
| First $1 million | 5% | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| Second $1 million | 4% | $40,000 | $90,000 |
| Third $1 million | 3% | $30,000 | $120,000 |
| Fourth $1 million | 2% | $20,000 | $140,000 |
| Everything above $4 million | 1% | $10,000 for each further $1 million | $140,000 plus 1% of the excess |
Worked examples: $1 million, $5 million and $20 million
Take $20 million. The first four slices total $140,000. The remaining $16 million is charged at 1%, which is $160,000. The Lehman fee is $300,000, or 1.5% of the price. Under the double Lehman every figure doubles: $280,000 plus 2% of $16 million ($320,000) is $600,000.
At $10 million the Lehman fee is $140,000 plus $60,000, which is $200,000. The double Lehman fee is $400,000.
| Deal value | Lehman fee | Effective rate | Double Lehman fee | Effective rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $1 million | $50,000 | 5.0% | $100,000 | 10.0% |
| $5 million | $150,000 | 3.0% | $300,000 | 6.0% |
| $10 million | $200,000 | 2.0% | $400,000 | 4.0% |
| $20 million | $300,000 | 1.5% | $600,000 | 3.0% |
The effective rate falls as the deal grows, which is the point of the scale.
What is a double Lehman?
The double Lehman keeps the $1 million slices and doubles the rates: "10% on the first million, plus 8% on the second million, plus 6% on the third million, plus 4% on the fourth million, plus 2% after that" (Morgan & Westfield). The same firm says most brokers selling businesses priced from $1 million to $5 million follow the double Lehman "or some version thereof".
Other variants exist. Wikipedia describes a "Double Percentage Lehman" that changes both the rates and the scale, and versions that keep the original rates but apply them to $10 million slices. When an engagement letter says "modified Lehman", ask for the table.
Is the Lehman formula still used?
As a reference point, yes. As the actual fee, less often. The original scale "was widely used in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s but is no longer the standard that it used to be due to inflation" (Wikipedia). A scale built around $1 million slices pays far less in real terms than it did when it was written.
Two things replaced it. On larger deals, advisers quote a negotiated percentage: Morgan & Westfield puts typical M&A adviser success fees "between 2% and 8%". On smaller ones, the double Lehman or a flat commission is common. The original formula also survives where the role is small: Wikipedia notes it "remains in use in limited situations with so-called" finders, people who introduce the parties and do nothing else in the deal.
Retainers, minimum fees and tail periods
The formula is only one line of an engagement letter. Three other terms often matter more.
- Retainer: for mid-sized businesses, "Most M&A advisors charge up-front fees, in addition to a success fee", from a few thousand dollars to more than $50,000 (Morgan & Westfield). Ask whether it is credited against the success fee.
- Minimum fee: the same source says most M&A advisers "have a minimum fee in the range of $50,000 to $250,000". On a small deal the minimum, not the formula, sets the fee.
- Tail period: a clause that keeps the fee payable if the business is sold, within a set time after the engagement ends, to a buyer the adviser introduced. The length and the list of covered buyers are negotiated. Read both before signing.
What do business brokers charge on smaller deals?
Below about $1 million the scale gives way to a flat commission. Morgan & Westfield reports that "Most brokers charge a flat 8% to 12% commission if the business is under $1 million", and that most business brokers "charge a minimum fee between $10,000 and $25,000 and work on a straight commission".
These are one firm's published description of the market, not a rate card. Every engagement is negotiated, and state law may require a business broker to hold a licence.
Common mistakes when reading a Lehman fee
Most fee disputes start with one of these.
- Applying the top rate to the whole price. Lehman on $5 million is $150,000, not 5% of $5 million.
- Leaving "deal value" undefined. Earn-outs, seller notes, assumed debt, retained cash and real estate can each be in or out. Write it down.
- Forgetting the minimum fee, which overrides the formula on small deals.
- Assuming the retainer is credited against the success fee when the letter does not say so.
- Ignoring the tail. A sale a year after the engagement ends can still carry the fee.
- Treating a finder like an adviser. Paying a success fee on a securities deal to someone who should be registered raises a FINRA Rule 2040 question.
When no sale happens: the company's records as a data asset
A success fee is paid on a closing. When an owner is not ready, or a process stalls, the formula pays nothing however much work went in. One asset can still earn in the meantime: the company's records. AI developers pay established companies to license years of work orders, quality files, project records and code, without buying the business. The company keeps its originals and approves every file.
Origin is an independent data partner. It values the records for free, prepares them with the owner and works with the AI companies and data buyers that license them. A licence must be disclosed in a later sale, so raise it before the letter of intent.
For advisers, the partner share is not a Lehman fee and not a percentage of the licence. A partner receives 50% of what Origin earns on the deal, up to $100,000 per company, paid after the deal completes. An introduction is credited for 12 months from the date it is registered, and a status page shows where each one stands. No fee is offered or paid to anyone acting for a bankruptcy estate, an assignment or a receivership.
Check your engagement letter first: if it covers all transactions of the business, a licence may fall inside it. Registered representatives must give their firm "prior written notice" before being paid for an outside activity (FINRA Rule 3270). The page for M&A advisers and business brokers sets out the rest.
Origin is independent. A buyer may pay Origin when a deal closes; your client pays Origin nothing.
Know a company with years of records? Get your partner link or introduce it to Origin.
Common questions
What is the Lehman formula?
A sliding scale for an M&A success fee: 5% of the first $1 million of deal value, 4% of the second, 3% of the third, 2% of the fourth and 1% of everything above $4 million. Each rate applies only to its own slice.
What is a double Lehman?
The same $1 million slices at double the rates: 10%, 8%, 6%, 4% and then 2% of everything above $4 million. On a $5 million sale it comes to $300,000, against $150,000 under the original formula.
Is the Lehman formula still used?
As a starting point more than as the final fee. Inflation has made the original scale small, so advisers use the double Lehman, other modified versions or a negotiated percentage, usually with a minimum fee.
Who pays the success fee?
The client who signed the engagement letter. In a sale that is normally the seller, and the fee is normally paid at closing. The letter decides, so read yours.
How do you calculate a Lehman fee on a $10 million deal?
Add the four slices ($50,000, $40,000, $30,000 and $20,000, which is $140,000) and 1% of the remaining $6 million ($60,000). The fee is $200,000, or 2% of the price. The double Lehman fee is $400,000.
What can an adviser earn when a client is not ready to sell?
Nothing under a success fee. If the client's records can be licensed to AI developers, an adviser who introduces the company to Origin receives 50% of what Origin earns on the deal, up to $100,000 per company, where the adviser's own rules allow it.
