- An ambient scribe drafts the note from the visit conversation; the clinician still reviews and signs it.
- Federal law allows recording with one party's consent, but Florida, Maryland and Washington require every party's consent, and Illinois and Massachusetts bar secret recording without it.
- Audio, transcripts and drafts can outlive the visit. HIPAA sets no retention period, so the practice and the vendor have to set one.
- The business associate agreement decides whether the vendor may de-identify visit data and what it may do with it.
What is an ambient scribe?
An ambient scribe, often called an AI medical scribe, is a tool that captures the conversation in an exam room or video visit and turns it into a draft clinical note. A review in CMAJ describes these tools: "These tools use speech recognition, natural language processing, and AI technologies to listen during a clinical encounter and generate clinical documentation." Then "Clinicians can then review, edit, and sign the generated note in the medical record" (CMAJ).
Ambient means the clinician talks to the patient, not to the software. A 2026 review explains that ambient scribes "differ from traditional speech-recognition dictation systems, in which the clinician actively dictates the note into a microphone" (Cureus). The Department of Veterans Affairs describes its own tool as technology that "captures natural patient-provider dialogue and generates progress notes in real time" (VA News).
Ambient clinical documentation is the wider term for the workflow: capture, transcription, a draft note, and clinician sign-off. The rest of this page covers how that works, the consent it needs and what happens to the recordings.
How does ambient clinical documentation work?
Products differ, but most follow the same five steps:
- Agreement. The clinician tells the patient and asks before starting. At the VA, "With a Veteran's verbal consent, Ambient Scribe processes the conversation to generate draft documentation" (VA News).
- Capture. A phone, tablet or room microphone picks up the visit. "In some products, this output is stored as a recording before being sent to the next stage; in others, the representation is processed in real time" (Cureus).
- Transcription and speakers. The software converts speech to text and labels who said what. A VA release says "Using AI, it identifies who is speaking, and summarizes the conversation into clear, structured notes" (VA Southern Nevada).
- Draft note. The transcript is turned into a note in the practice's format, often with the history, exam, assessment and plan in separate sections.
- Review and sign. VA notes are "reviewed and edited by providers to ensure accuracy and completeness before being signed into the" health record (VA News).
The review step is not a formality. "Clinical documentation generated by AI scribes may contain errors and must always be reviewed", including "hallucinations (i.e., documenting things that did not occur) or omission of key information" (CMAJ). The clinician who signs is responsible for the note.
Do patients have to consent to an ambient scribe recording a visit?
It depends on the state, and good practice asks everyone. Federal law permits a recording "where such person is a party to the communication or where one of the parties to the communication has given prior consent to such interception" (18 U.S.C. 2511). The clinician is a party, so federal law alone would allow it. Several states require every party to agree. This page is general information, not legal advice.
| State | What the statute says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Florida | Interception is lawful "when all of the parties to the communication have given prior consent to such interception" | Fla. Stat. 934.03 |
| Illinois | Bars recording a private conversation "unless he or she does so with the consent of all other parties to the private conversation" | 720 ILCS 5/14-2 |
| Maryland | Lawful where "all of the parties to the communication have given prior consent to the interception" | Md. Courts and Judicial Proceedings 10-402 |
| Massachusetts | Secret recording by anyone other than "a person given prior authority by all parties to such communication" is an interception | M.G.L. c. 272, s. 99 |
| Washington | Recording a private conversation requires "the consent of all the persons engaged in the conversation" | RCW 9.73.030 |
These five are the statutes read for this page, not a full list. A 2026 review notes that "statutory requirements for recorded conversations vary across US jurisdictions" (Cureus), and a video visit can put the patient and the clinician in different states, so check both.
HIPAA itself does not require a patient's signed authorization for the scribe, because documentation is part of the practice's own care and operations (45 CFR 164.506) and the vendor works as a business associate (45 CFR 164.502). The consent question comes from state recording law and from patient trust. The VA lets patients opt out: "Veterans can opt out at any time, even mid-visit" (VA News), and "Use of Ambient AI Scribe is always optional for Veterans" (VA Southern Nevada).
What should patients be told before an ambient scribe is used?
Enough to make a real choice. One review says consent works "when patients understand that the encounter may be recorded or otherwise captured, that information from the encounter will be processed into a draft note, that the draft may require clinician correction, and that data handling and retention practices may vary" (Cureus). Patients may also want to know "whether those materials are used for system improvement or model training, and whether they may decline use without compromising care".
How much detail matters. In a study of 121 users (18 clinicians and 103 patients) at one academic health center, "The most common consent approach was a verbal patient-clinician conversation prior to an individual encounter." The share agreeing moved with the detail given: "when provided basic information about the technology, 84 patients (81.6%) consented; this decreased to 57 patients (55.3%) when details about AI features, data storage, and corporate involvement were disclosed" (JAMA Network Open).
Write a short script the whole practice uses, put the same words on a sign and in the patient portal, and record the patient's answer in the chart for every visit. Visits with sensitive topics, such as substance use or mental health, are a reason to ask again or switch the scribe off.
What does an ambient scribe keep: audio, transcript or note?
Up to five kinds of material, and only one of them is the note in the chart. A 2026 review warns that "Acoustic recordings, transcripts, draft notes, metadata, and other processing artifacts retained by vendors or health systems may persist outside the clinical record and become relevant in litigation or regulatory review" (Cureus).
| Material | What it is | Question to settle with the vendor |
|---|---|---|
| Audio recording | The captured visit, if the product stores it | Is audio kept at all, and for how many days? |
| Transcript | Speaker-labeled text of the visit | Is it deleted after sign-off, kept by the vendor, or attached to the chart? |
| Draft note | The unsigned note and the clinician's edits | Are drafts and edit history kept, and where? |
| Signed note | The final note in the EHR | Part of the medical record under state retention rules |
| Metadata and logs | Timestamps, user and device logs, model versions | Who can see them, and for how long? |
Ask whether any of it becomes part of the designated record set, which HIPAA defines to include "The medical records and billing records about individuals maintained by or for a covered health care provider" and records "Used, in whole or in part, by or for the covered entity to make decisions about individuals" (45 CFR 164.501). Patients can request access to that set, so the answer matters.
Clinicians want these answers too: in the same study, "Many were unsure about how data were stored or secured and wanted more information about data practices prior to using the technology with patients" (JAMA Network Open).
How long should ambient scribe recordings and transcripts be kept?
HIPAA does not set the period. HHS says "No, the HIPAA Privacy Rule does not include medical record retention requirements. Rather, State laws generally govern how long medical records are to be retained" (HHS). The signed note follows the state rule for medical records; see how long patient records are kept by state.
For audio and transcripts the practice and the vendor choose, and safeguards apply "for whatever period such information is maintained by a covered entity, including through disposal" (HHS). Shorter is easier to defend: less to secure, less to produce in a dispute. Longer can help quality review. Whatever the choice, put it in writing, make sure the vendor's settings match, and ask for confirmation when audio is deleted.
Who controls ambient scribe recordings under a business associate agreement?
The practice does, through the contract. A scribe vendor that receives visit audio is a business associate, and "A business associate may use or disclose protected health information only as permitted or required by its business associate contract or other arrangement" (45 CFR 164.502). The contract must say the vendor will "Not use or further disclose the information other than as permitted or required by the contract or as required by law", must flow the same limits to subcontractors, and at the end must require it to "return or destroy all protected health information" it still holds and "retain no copies of such information" where feasible (45 CFR 164.504).
One clause decides the most. HHS's sample provisions say "the parties should specify whether the business associate is authorized to use protected health information to de-identify the information in accordance with 45 CFR 164.514(a)-(c)", and may set "the permitted uses and disclosures by the business associate of the de-identified information" (HHS). That clause is where a vendor gets, or does not get, the right to turn your patients' visits into training data for its own models. Read it before signing, and again at renewal.
| Clause | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Permitted uses | Documentation for the practice only, or broader product uses |
| De-identification | Whether the vendor may de-identify, by which method, and for what |
| Use of de-identified data | Internal improvement only, model training, or sharing with others |
| Retention and deletion | Days of audio and transcript retention, and deletion on request |
| Subcontractors | Cloud and transcription providers bound by the same limits |
| Termination | Return or destruction, with written confirmation |
Example: a four-clinician practice sets up an ambient scribe (illustration)
This is an illustration written for this page. A fictional four-clinician family practice in Maryland, an all-party consent state, writes down its decisions before the first visit is recorded.
| Decision | What the practice chose | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Consent | A spoken script at the start of each visit, a sign in each room, and the answer recorded in the chart | Maryland requires all parties to consent |
| Who is in the room | Ask any family member or caregiver present as well | They are parties to the conversation too |
| Sensitive visits | Scribe off by default for behavioral health and substance use visits | Patient trust and stricter federal rules on those records |
| Audio | Deleted by the vendor within 7 days of sign-off | Enough time to check a disputed note |
| Transcripts and drafts | Deleted with the audio; only the signed note stays in the EHR | One record to keep and produce |
| De-identified use by the vendor | Not allowed without a separate written agreement | The practice keeps that decision |
| End of contract | Return or destroy, with a signed certificate | Matches the business associate rule |
Fictional example written for this page. The practice reviews the settings each year and whenever the vendor changes its terms.
Common mistakes with ambient scribes
Most problems come from switching the tool on before the paperwork is done.
- Relying on federal one-party consent in a state that requires every party to agree.
- Asking the patient but not the family member or interpreter in the room.
- Signing notes without reading them, so errors and invented details reach the chart.
- Leaving the vendor's default retention in place without knowing what it is.
- Accepting a business associate agreement that lets the vendor use de-identified visit data for anything.
- Recording sensitive visits by default.
- Having no way to delete a recording when a patient withdraws consent mid-visit.
For the rules on psychotherapy notes, which stay separate even when a scribe drafts the progress note, see psychotherapy notes.
Are visit recordings and transcripts a data asset?
They can be, and they are now the newest kind of health data in demand. AI data buyers have asked Origin for longitudinal EHR records (patient records over time with diagnoses, medications, labs and outcomes), imaging with reports (CT, MRI, X-ray and pathology slides), behavioral health and specialty care records, and doctor-patient conversation audio with transcripts, which is the newest request. Real visits matter because they show how clinicians and patients actually talk, and the linked note shows what a trained person decided to write down.
The buyers have also said what these deals need to get through: de-identification signed off by an independent third party under HIPAA's Expert Determination method, not by the seller; IRB approval, or patient consent that covers commercial licensing; and a clear chain of rights showing who collected the data, who owns it and who can license it. What must come out first: voices and spoken identifiers, since HIPAA's Safe Harbor list includes "Biometric identifiers, including finger and voice prints" (45 CFR 164.514); visits recorded without the consent the state requires; recordings the business associate agreement does not let anyone use this way; and behavioral health sessions. The guide to licensing telehealth visit recordings covers consent wording and de-identifying audio in detail.
Origin is an independent data partner. It does not perform Expert Determination or IRB review. It helps a practice work out what records it holds, which of these three requirements it already meets and what is missing. The practice decides what is shared and signs any license itself, and a buyer may pay Origin when a deal closes.
Does your company hold records like these? See what your data is worth.
Common questions
Is an ambient scribe the same as an AI medical scribe?
Mostly, yes. Both terms describe software that listens to a clinical visit and drafts the clinician's note from the conversation. "Ambient" stresses that the tool listens in the background while the clinician talks to the patient, unlike dictation, where the clinician speaks to the software. Either way, the clinician must review, edit and sign the note.
Do patients have to agree before an ambient scribe records a visit?
In some states, yes by law. Federal law allows recording with one party's consent, but Florida, Maryland and Washington require every party's consent, Illinois and Massachusetts bar secret recording without it, and other states may have similar rules. The VA asks every patient and lets them opt out, even mid-visit. Record the answer in the chart.
Does an ambient scribe vendor need a business associate agreement?
Yes, when it receives or keeps patient information for a covered practice. The vendor is a business associate, may use the information only as its contract allows, must pass the same limits to its subcontractors, and must return or destroy the information when the contract ends where feasible. The agreement should also say whether the vendor may de-identify visit data.
How long are ambient scribe recordings kept?
It depends on the product and the contract. Some products process audio in real time; others store a recording first. HIPAA sets no retention period, so the practice and the vendor decide, and the signed note follows state medical record rules. Ask the vendor for its default settings in writing and change them if they are longer than you need.
Can a patient say no to an ambient scribe?
Yes. The practice can still document the visit the usual way, with the clinician typing or dictating the note. In states that require every party's consent, the visit may not be recorded without the patient's agreement. The VA, for example, makes its scribe optional for every patient and lets patients opt out at any time, even in the middle of a visit.
Can an ambient scribe vendor use visit recordings to train its AI?
Only as far as its business associate agreement allows. HHS sample provisions say the agreement should state whether the vendor may de-identify the information and what it may do with de-identified data. If the agreement is silent or limits use to the practice's documentation, the vendor has no right to train its own models on those visits.
Is the ambient scribe transcript part of the medical record?
The signed note is. Whether the transcript and audio are depends on how the practice keeps and uses them: HIPAA's designated record set includes records used to make decisions about patients. A practice can keep only the signed note and have the vendor delete the rest, which leaves one clear record. Settle this in writing with the vendor before the first visit.
Sources and further reading
- CMAJ, via PubMed Central: Artificial intelligence scribes in primary care (2024)
- Cureus, via PubMed Central: From Clinical Encounter to Draft Documentation, a review of ambient scribe technology (2026)
- JAMA Network Open, via PubMed Central: Informed Consent for Ambient Documentation Using Generative AI in Ambulatory Care (2025)
- VA News: Ambient Scribe reimagines the VA clinic experience (July 29, 2026)
- VA Southern Nevada Health Care: VA's Ambient AI Scribe initiative (March 3, 2026)
- 18 U.S.C. 2511: interception of wire, oral or electronic communications (govinfo)
- Florida Statutes 934.03 (Florida Senate)
- Illinois Compiled Statutes, 720 ILCS 5/14-2 (Illinois General Assembly)
- Maryland Code, Courts and Judicial Proceedings 10-402 (Maryland General Assembly)
- Massachusetts General Laws, chapter 272, section 99 (Massachusetts Legislature)
- Revised Code of Washington 9.73.030 (Washington State Legislature)
- 45 CFR 164.501: definitions (eCFR)
- 45 CFR 164.502: uses and disclosures of protected health information, general rules (eCFR)
- 45 CFR 164.504: business associate contracts (eCFR)
- 45 CFR 164.506: uses and disclosures for treatment, payment and health care operations (eCFR)
- 45 CFR 164.514: de-identification of protected health information (eCFR)
- HHS: Does the HIPAA Privacy Rule require covered entities to keep medical records for any period of time?
- HHS: Business Associate Contracts, sample business associate agreement provisions
